[Battle Review] Shampoo and Conditioner Schwarkopf Hydro Collagen vs. Herbal Essences Hello Hydration

Today there will be battle between Schwarkopf Hydro Collagen vs. Herbal Essences Hello Hydration. Both are shampoo and conditioner for dry hair. I had used Schwarkopf for more than two weeks and Herbal Essences for a month. I used both their shampoo and conditioner. 

Schwarkopf and Herbal Essences Shampoo and Conditioner

From the packaging, both of the product use the color of blue. Schwarkopf shampoo and conditioner are bigger than Herbal Essences's. Schwarkopf shampoo is 200 ml while its conditioner is 175 ml. Both Herbal Essences shampoo and conditioner are 160 ml each. For the packaging, I like the Schwarkopf because it's easy to open. Yeah, I know it's personal. 
 Their packaging

For the review, first, I will focus on the shampoo. Schwarkopf shampoo claims that it's liquid hair repair that contains liquid keratin. The bottle says that it's nourishing moisture, shine, and supplement for dry and coarse hair. The moisturizing formula (collagen and hyaluronan) based on the proven result helps restore moisture balance for softer and shinier hair. 

Herbal Essences shampoo contains a fusion of orchid and coconut milk that help moisturing dry and damaged hair. It leaves hair silky and supple.You can check both of the ingredients below.

Their Ingredients

For the consistency, you will find that Schwarkopf shampoo is more watery than Herbal Essences. Herbal Essences consistency is lotion. Actually, for shampoo, I prefer Schwarkopf because it's easy to mix with water before applying on my hair. But sadly, I don't really like the scent of Schwarkopf shampoo. It smells like chemical things. I hate it. I think Schwarkopf should make some effort to make their product smell good. Herbal Essences has flowery and coconut smell. I like it very much.

Their consistency

For the conditioner, both of them have the same claim with their shampoo. They help moisturizing the dry hair. The consistency of both conditioner are similar, lotion, but Schwarkopf has color white while Herbal Essences is blue. The contains of two conditioner is on the picture below. 

Ingredients on both conditioner

 The consistency of both conditioner

Result in my hair : 
Schwarkopf's products don't make my hair softer like its claims. I think that my hair getting worse after I used it for two weeks. My hair became more frizzy and drier. It may because my hair characteristic didn't react good with too many chemical things. It may better for your hair, not mine. I stopped using this product. 
Repurchase : No.
Price          : Less than IDR 50,000 (USD 5) each.

Herbal Essences shampoo gave result as its claims. It makes my hair silky. But it makes my hair better than before, not as good as I want. I like the smell. Maybe I will buy other version of Herbal Essences shampoo. I had used the Herbal Essences anti Frizzy hair and they worked better for me than this dry varian. 
Repurchase : Maybe.
Price          : Less than IDR 20,000 (USD 2) each.


0 komentar:

Posting Komentar

Jejak Venus Blog Design by Ipietoon